Below are messages we published on August 1, 2012, from readers who wanted to express their gratitude for our site. We continue to get private messages like these everyday.
******************************************************************************
“Bless You! Bless You All! I want to hug your necks, kiss your faces, bow down at your feet, and toss roses whenever you walk. I’ve stopped responding on GR because of FEAR, after watching my very good friends go through the absolute misery of being on the receiving end of HATE. The bully reader mentality has gotten so out of hand; reading the post about the GR bully culture made me want to cry. You have NO IDEA what an impact you all are making doing this. PLEASE DON’T STOP! These are grown women doing these spiteful, hateful acts and they need to be called out and held accountable for their actions. You have my full support. Whatever you need. THANK YOU from the bottom of my heart.”
“God bless you for this site. I have been near tears over some of this stuff. Keep up the good work! The Holy Terror, Lucy, Ridley… the whole lot of them are torturers. My Goodreads tags are just vile and hurtful. It’s unbelievable how many of my comments were taken out of context or twisted. It’s been awful. These people are totally crazy. Thank you!!!”
“I just wanted to say thank you for the work you are doing. I have not experienced any bullying by readers or other writers but I see it and it really is a sad situation. I feel like a second class citizen as an author sometimes. Your site was linked to on Kindle Boards and that’s how I found it. Just wanted to say that you are doing a good work.”
“Just contacting you to say, as an author, I think what you’re doing is wonderful. I’ve not faced bullying on GR, personally, but I know people who have. And I have been the victim of “troll ratings” (when a reader gives you one star before a book is even released in order to bring your rating down from the start, I assume, just for funsies?) Anyway, thank you! You guys are too cool for school.”
“I am so glad you have this site up and running. Don’t ever shut it down. It’s one thing for me to have been bullied off GR, but it’s a whole new level as they’ve attacked my personal web accounts. These people need to be stopped.”
“Athena, thank you! I will be watching and hoping you and yours can bring them to their knees.”
“This is a day to celebrate! I’ve been a victim of Ridley and co’s scathing reviews, their goading, their swearing, their pack mentality. Up until maybe 3 months ago, I had no idea this was going on at GR. After I fell into their well baited trap, I contacted Goodreads to see if there was something we could do without agitating her more. Basically they said she could say and do what she pleased. They admitted that some readers/reviewers could make an author’s life extremely uncomfortable. I won’t be going near GR again. Also, I think I’m right in believing that some of Ridley and co’s reviews and nasty comments to other readers on Amazon were recently taken down. And so the blessed wheel turns!! Thanks SO much again. Behind you 100%.”
“I’ve been following this blog for several weeks now and have finally felt compelled to share my thoughts on this whole… Honestly I don’t have any words for it. I’m appalled and am left speechless each time I come across anything to do with GR bullies.”
I’m a book blogger, reviewer, and also a writer. At first I was sceptical about your blog because I don’t see how pointing out and show-casing certain unpleasant reviewers is mature or going to help at all.
However, yes there’s a however, I’ve begun to come around. I’ve always known there were reviewers out there who liked to criticise negatively, but it wasn’t until I read a few of those reviews on GR when I realised how far they can go. Since I’ve read those reviews I have avoided reading all reviews posted. Not only are they not helpful, but they are also extremely rude, offensive, and I don’t understand the need for so much anger and hate. It’s inane and irrational to me to react as they do. If you’ve disliked a book that much and can’t pick up any deeper meanings then just move on. It would be the easier option, I imagine.
What I would like to express to you guys is a thank you. Without your blog I doubt I would have learnt how bad these reviews and their creators are and what reviewers to avoid, not only for their upsetting behaviour, but also because these are the type of people I wish to always avoid. If your blog has had this effect on me, I like to think it has brought awareness to other readers and reviewers.”
“Wow, I was shocked to find your website/blog, especially because I’ve encountered some of the nastiness of the GR gang firsthand. Recently one of my friends, a fellow author, was publicly ridiculed by a reader/reviewer, and this reviewer’s friends all joined in and mocked the book in question as well as the author. My friend was so mortified and demoralized that she quit GR altogether. She posted a blog about her decision, which I commented on, lending support. In my comment I advised her not to take to heart the nasty comments and to realize that there are times when it is not the author who is incompetent but rather the reader. My comment was not directed at any one in particular. Well, this posse of haters then came upon the blog and went after me. They began posting general updates on their GR walls warning other readers to avoid my books because I had supposedly said that all readers are incompetent. They went on to say that I would pay a price for speaking my mind. At the time all of this was occurring, I posted a blog on GR about it, but all it managed to accomplish was to draw the attention of this same group of hateful people and they began attacking me there as well. I ended up deleting the entire thread. I find it interesting that others have had these experiences on GR, and that it is so prevalent that a website was created.”
“I would just like to say thank for this site. I believe I was one of the first to fall victim to these people. I commented on a bashing session they did on Becca Fitzpatrick. they pounced and pounced big. Holy terror hit me first, then Cory (who I was told by one of their minions is a 14 year old high school student, and who’s parents work all day so she can do as she pleases.) This same minion told me I did nothing wrong, that they were sorry, and told me not to delete, that they would calm down. Well, it was just teamwork. I went to the woman’s profile and she laughed about how much I trusted her, that she got me to stay, and to “have at me”. Holy Terror and this other woman Lethal Lovely then threatened me publicly and in emails (I had given said woman my email to share amazon loanable books, this woman also shared that she hasn’t “bought a book in a year, she gets them from download sites”). But I digress. When I emailed goodreads with all my proof, screencaps, IP addresses, I was told I should leave goodreads. ME! So, I did. I am back now but have them all blocked. I have to be honest and say I am not sure why these women are still around. I’m surprised no one has sued them to be frank. A lot of what they do is slander, which is illegal.”
“I think you are doing a wonderful service for authors. I’ve been writing over 20 years, have worked with magazines, newspapers, and a variety of web sites catering to authors and writers. At Goodreads and Amazon, my books usually have bad reviews. I even participated in a Goodreads book give-away, where it is implied you will get a review from the winner, and, no review. That was a year ago. I know a little about writing and, for some reason, as soon as several titles came out, they were hit with a really bad review. One was even just an informal non-fic to help other parents (my son is autistic). The only review for it even now is 1-star that actually states I have factually incorrect information in the book (no, I don’t). Another non-fic on local history got a bad review and the reviewer didn’t even have the right price in their review. I don’t know why, but I know it hurts sales. Recently, on Goodreads, I participated in a discussion about authors and reviewers. Sadly, that got me another 2-star rating. Authors don’t really have any resource for help. Reviewing bloggers may or may not give you a review and professional reviewers commonly charge $400 or $500 for a single review. Thanks again.”
“I just wanted to thank you, I have almost stopped going to the site because I hated the drama. I hope they see the point when the admins of GR visit your site.”